Cedar Creek Natural History Area: Literature   Up   Home


Citation. Tilman, D.; Wedin, D. 1991. Dynamics of nitrogen competition between successional grasses. Ecology 72:1038-1049. (Highlighted in Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 1991).   [1185  LTER]

Abstract. Pairwise competition experiments were performed for 3 yr on an experimental nitrogen gradient at Cedar Creek Natural History Area, Minnesota, where N is the major limiting resource during early succession. Agrostis scabra, an early successional grass, competed against another early (Agropyron repens), a later (Schizachyrium scoparium), and an even later (Andropogon gerardi) successional species. On low N soils, Agrostis was competitively displaced by each of the later successional species, but persisted with Agropyron. On high N soils, Agrostis was displaced by all three of the other species. The inferior competitive ability for N of the early successional species refutes the resource ratio hypothesis of succession. Rather, the high allocation of Agrostis to seed and its rapid colonization of fields support a colonization-competition hypothesis of succession. For two of three cases, the outcome of competition on low nitrogen soils was predicted by R*, the nitrogen concentration to which monocultures of each species reduced extractable soil nitrate and ammonium on N-limited soils. In these cases, the species with the significantly lower R* for nitrogen displaced the other species. In the third case, the species had more similar R* values, and the species with the lower R* had not displaced the other species within 3 yr (but it had done so after 5 yr; see Note added in proof).

Keywords. Agropyron repens, Agrostis scabra, Andropogon gerardi, colonization, grasses, nutrient reduction, plant competition, R*, resource competition theory, Schizachyrium scoparium, succession

For reprints or technical issues, please correspond with the author of the paper. For comments on the format or contents of the web site, please contact webmaster@cedarcreek.umn.edu