|
‘This is Cedar Creek?’
I thought to myself as I pulled into the parking lot. I was in front of
a small, single-story tan building whose brown windowsills were crying
out for a paint job. This was where the discipline of ecosystem ecology
was essentially invented in the 1940s by a young graduate student named
Raymond Lindeman, and ever since then ecologists at Cedar Creek Natural
History Area have been turning out research that ranks among the most
important in the field. But this building did not look like a first rate
research institution to me. Of course, that is because I was forgetting
that when you have 9 square miles of some of the most ecologically diverse
land in Minnesota, huge laboratories are not so important. Currently,
there are two really large-scale, long-term experiments, known as BioCON
and LTER, being run at Cedar Creek, and both of them are examining the
implications of biodiversity - the number of different species coexisting
in a particular ecosystem. The credits for these experiments are peppered
with the big names of ecology, but at the heart of it all lie the interns
of Cedar Creek. I was there to work with them and discover the intern
experience first hand.
 |
 |
| The main building of Cedar Creek, where offices and laboratories
are |
Working out in the BioCON experiment |
This summer about 50 interns are working at Cedar Creek. Most are in
their early 20s, biology majors from colleges and universities in nearly
20 different states as well as Canada and the Bahamas. My first exposure
to the interns was a conversation I overheard at lunch. To be more exact,
it was a lively argument about an unknown plant, as much in Latin as in
English, with scientific names being bandied about that sounded to me
remarkably like spells from Harry Potter.
“I really think it looks like Solidego canadensis.”
“No way, there’s not a hair on it.”
“I’m telling you, it’s missouriensis.”
“Well, I think it’s Nemoralis.”
“WHAT?!!!”
To do their jobs it is essential that the interns be able to recognize
and distinguish the experimental species, so after lunch I was given a
crash course on how to identify the different grassland plant species
that grow here at Cedar Creek. I learned about the palmate (fan like)
and pinnate (feather like) leaves that are found on plants from the legume
family. I found out what a clasping auricle (pronounced “oracle”)
is – it is the bottom of a grass blade that wraps around and hugs
its stem, rather than just being attached to it. I discovered that the
grass I like to blow on and make squeak is known as Bromus inermis. And,
the sneaking suspicion that I had developed at lunch was confirmed; I
was in for far more than I had expected. But, before I had time to steep
in the recognition of my botanical ignorance, I hurdled headlong into
working with the BioCON crew.
The BioCON experiment examines what role plant biodiversity may play in
the future. Different numbers of plant species are grown in small plots
of land that are given a high level of nitrogen in the soil and a high
level of carbon dioxide in the air (twice as high as in the normal environment!)
to simulate what scientists predict the environmental conditions will
be in the year 2050. All sorts of data are collected from these plots
and the health of the soil and the plants is evaluated. I joined the BioCON
interns during harvest week, when swaths of plants are clipped from each
plot and the different species are sorted from one another to be dried
and later weighed. I was awestruck as I watched the sorters deftly identify
even the most diminutive snippets of grass. I became persuaded that the
grasses were revealing their identities through some barely perceptible
herbaceous communication, so I concentrated with all my mental capacity
on the blade between my fingers. There was no distinct aura, no helpful
whisper of “Agropyron repens”. I had to ask my table partner
for help.
 |
 |
| An intern student supervisor double checking a sorting job. |
Sorting |
Sorting plants for hours may not seem like the most thrilling of tasks,
but the BioCONers were a lively crew and amused themselves with chatting,
laughing, singing and snacking on candy. This laid back atmosphere is
one of the things many interns told me they loved about Cedar Creek. Though
the results they were working towards may well be published someday in
a prestigious journal, there is no overwhelming sense of pressure to perform.
In fact, it is even perfectly acceptable to nickname the experimental
plant species. Bouteloua gracilis becomes “Booty”, Schizachyrium
scoparium becomes “Skiz”, and so on. We had just finished
a stirring rendition of “Bohemian Rhapsody” when one of the
intern supervisors announced that it was time to go clip. Six people rose
to leave, and I tagged along.
We drove out to the fields where the experimental plots lay, encircled
by tall white pipes that were blowing out CO2 (the control plots were
also surrounded by pipes, but these were blowing normal air), and pulled
up to circle number 5. The crew members grabbed plastic trays and battery-run
clippers that made me think of bear paws with vicious claws, except the
would be paws were yellow and plastic. The interns fanned out, each taking
a different plot, clipping a 10cm by 1m path through the plants, collecting
everything they clipped into a plastic tray and labeling it, and then
moving on to a new plot. It looked easy enough, so I offered my helpful
services. Very quickly I learned two things: first, when you are running
ferocious clippers along the ground you should grab plants by their tops,
not their bases (don’t worry, I still have all my fingers); second,
even if elevated CO2 levels don’t affect the importance of biodiversity
(though results thus far indicate they do) they definitely affect mosquito
levels. Attracted to the piped carbon dioxide as they would be to the
CO2 respired by any sanguine animal, billowing clouds of mosquitoes swarmed
the ring and motivated us all to clip as efficiently as possible. After
finishing the ring, we returned to the sorting room, itchy but refreshed
from the excursion. We continued to sort for the afternoon until the staff
supervisor showed up with a surprise - sumptuous chocolate layer cakes
to thank the team for being such hard workers.
I would have happily worked many more days with BioCON, if they had kept
feeding me cake, but I was slated to spend the next day with LTER. So,
early the next morning 15 interns and I piled into a rickety 1986 suburban
– the doors were barely attached and the windows were crusted with
mosquito carcasses – and we drove out to some of the LTER experimental
plots, known affectionately as “Big Bio”. LTER (which stands
for Long Term Ecological Research) examines many of the same things as
BIOCON but without the elevated nitrogen and CO2. In other words, it is
testing the role of biodiversity here and now. That day we were going
to weed, making sure that only the desired experimental species were left
in each plot because extra weeds growing would create extra biodiversity
and taint the experiment’s results. The sun was rising, golden and
hazy, over the expanses of green field, but we were nearly oblivious to
its beauty. We were focused on the cold. It was freezing, more like March
than June, and a stiff wind was whipping in from the north. We steeled
ourselves and started working.
 |
 |
| A cold day for weeding |
The vehicle of choice at Cedar Creek |
The first plot was a breeze. We pulled the smattering of weeds and moved
on. When we stopped at the next plot the intern supervisor checked her
clipboard and looked up with horror in her eyes. “This is a Lespedeza,
Achillea, and Sorghastrum culture,” she announced. From my sorting
I knew what all those plants looked like, and when I surveyed the plot
I saw almost none of them. “Are you sure?” asked some of the
interns, dismayed. The supervisor checked again and nodded; it was true,
the plot was almost nothing but weeds. We plunked ourselves down, trying
not to squish anything important and started weeding for all we were worth.
My knees and back started to ache. My fingers were grimy and began to
go numb from the cold. Even the antifreeze running through my Minnesotan
veins wasn’t enough to combat the fact that I was not properly dressed
for 40-something degree weather. I was getting chilled to the core and
having to sniffle furiously to prevent my nose from running all over my
face. “What time is it?” I asked. Not even 10 o’clock
yet, impossible!
I was about ready to throw in the towel, but all the other interns were
working steadily away revealing no signs of needing a break. Ashamed of
my wimpiness, I jabbed extra hard at a clump of unwanted grass with my
pronged weeding tool and somehow managed to spray a torrent of soil into
my face. I plugged on. Not that long after, a cry rose up across the fields
that was music to our ears. “Hot cocoa!” Troy, the research
coordinator, had arrived bearing two large pots of piping hot chocolate
– a gesture that instantly catapulted him to a position high on
my list of all time favorite people. Revived by the warmth and the sugar
we returned to weeding, discussing our coldest moments and grooving a
little to music from a stereo that one girl was wearing like a backpack.
With all this sorting, clipping, and weeding, the work at Cedar Creek
may seem more like large-scale gardening than science, but the interns
said that they do feel involved in the results that come out of here.
“Sure we pretty much do a lot of grunt work,” one girl explained
to me, “but we always know what’s going on. They make sure
we understand what we’re doing things for.” To promote this
understanding, scientists often come out to Cedar Creek specifically to
present their research and results to the interns in seminars and symposia.
The interns are also given the opportunity to propose an individual research
idea and carry out their own experimental work with the help of a member
of the Cedar Creek staff. Analyzing the effects of nitrogen on pond invertebrates
and measuring the effect of ground compression (from walking on it, for
example) on the productivity of different plants are two of the many project
ideas that interns told me about. This educational aspect is one of the
most important parts of interning at Cedar Creek. |